The Central Government has been questioned by the Supreme Court on the need for extending the tenure of incumbent Delhi Chief Secretary Naresh Kumar.
A bench comprising of Chief Justice of India (CJI) DY Chandrachud as well as Justice JB Pardiwala and Justice Manoj Misra have questioned the Solicitor General (SG) Tushar Mehta as to why the government was only recommending one person to be Chief Secretary of Delhi.
The bench remarked that do they have no other IAS officer who can be recommended as the Chief Secretary.
You can appoint whoever you want. Why are you stuck only one who can be the Chief Secretary of Delhi.
The Court granted the SG time till tomorrow to demonstrate the Central government’s power to extend the Chief Secretary’s tenure.
The Court asked the government to show them the powers to extend by tomorrow. or else just make the appointment.
The Apex Court was hearing plea filed by Delhi government opposing the extension of the incumbent Chief Secretary’s tenure or the unilateral appointment of a new official by the Central government.
The Delhi government was represented by Senior Advocate AM Singhvi, who said that the appearing for the Delhi government, urged the Court to consider alternatives and suggested selecting a candidate from a panel or appointing the senior-most IAS officer.
The Delhi government council questioned about the extension being a unilateral decision, bypassing established procedures.
The Delhi Government Counsel Singhvi highlighted that the Apex court itself had ruled that the Lieutenant Governor was bound by the aid and advice of the Council of Ministers.
However, the Court pointed out that The Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi (Amendment) Act, 2023 was in force which grants the Central government power to appoint the Chief Secretary of Delhi.
As such, the Court suggested going as per law. It, however, asked the Central government not to extend the tenure of the current Chief Secretary but to make a fresh appointment.
SG Mehta, however, insisted that the Central government has the power to extend the appointment.
Accordingly, the Court granted the SG time till tomorrow to demonstrate the same.